用户头像 点击登录
儿童
普通
限制
用户头像 点击登录

"Bright sword" is also an anti Japanese drama? Of course, the difference between 50 steps and 100 steps

When the famous detective Conan: The Scarlet bullet was released, Hideki Akai's shooting method of "shooting a devil 800 miles away" aroused heated discussion, and once again turned out the old topic of Anti Japanese drama.

《亮剑》也算抗日神剧?当然,五十步和一百步的区别

A kind of spoof is popular on the short video platform. Mass actors further "deify" various anti Japanese Shenju bridge segments and shoot various wonderful effects. Some viewers can recognize it at a glance. It's just a short video clip. Just make you laugh. But some viewers can't recognize it and mistakenly think that this is the bridge of an anti Japanese divine drama. There's no way. After all, people like the author who comment on the code words of TV dramas every day sometimes can't tell the difference between some anti Japanese divine dramas and funny jokes.

Anti Japanese drama has become a cultural phenomenon, which has to make people think deeply. When did this idea of filming begin?

So someone said that this is the beginning of "Liangjian", which is the ancestor of Anti Japanese drama.

《亮剑》也算抗日神剧?当然,五十步和一百步的区别

This view has a market on the Internet and is not groundless. Many people can cite several examples to support this view. In this regard, the author's view is that "Liangjian" can also be regarded as an anti Japanese drama in a certain sense, which is only 50 steps and 100 steps different from those later "hand tearing devils".

《亮剑》也算抗日神剧?当然,五十步和一百步的区别

1、 There are some elements of divine drama in Liangjian

In the battle of lijiapo, in order to shape the image of Li Yunlong, the combat level of brother troops and Japanese troops was seriously weakened.

This battle is the redemption battle between Li Yunlong and Kong erlengzi in the light of the sword. It is a very beautiful battle, which is based on the battle of Guan jianao in history.

However, in this part of the play, the achievements of other Eighth Route Army troops were blurred by the director, and the combat ability of the Japanese army was weakened. In fact, the battle of guanjianao was very fierce, and the enemy was not eliminated completely. The movie "shining sword" was filmed with some magic.

《亮剑》也算抗日神剧?当然,五十步和一百步的区别

For example, Li Yunlong's earth excavation has a prototype in history, but people dig holes on the hillside behind the enemy, and the enemy doesn't know. Li Yunlong is digging a pit dozens of meters away from the Japanese army. Aren't you afraid that the Japanese army will throw you a cantaloupe grenade? You can throw it, people can't throw it? Therefore, this paragraph is a modification of the historical prototype.

《亮剑》也算抗日神剧?当然,五十步和一百步的区别

The ambush of the Japanese army officers' sightseeing group was based on the historical prototype of the ambush in hanlue village. The process was quite similar. Wang Jinshan, then head of the 16th regiment of the 386 brigade, found a fighter plane on his way to Yan'an and decided to ambush, but some cadres thought that their task was not allowed to do so, so Wang Jinshan asked the political commissar to escort the cadres' families with two battalions first, He led the second battalion to fight the North China Japanese army observation group in hanlue village.

The play of "shining sword" is very similar to the prototype story, but it is very different. Wang Jinshan ambushed him on the way to Yan'an. Chen Geng gave him the order not to love war but not to be able to fight on the way. In the sword, Li Yunlong's task is to protect the headquarters of the Eighth Route Army, and the headquarters of the Eighth Route Army has indeed been attacked. Even the deputy commander in chief has to take temporary refuge. It can be seen that the priorities of Wang Jinshan and Li Yunlong are very different.

《亮剑》也算抗日神剧?当然,五十步和一百步的区别

Let's put it this way. According to the plot of "shining the sword", Li Yunlong's crime in this battle is enough to be shot, and it is impossible for his merits and demerits to offset each other. Disobedience on the battlefield has put the headquarters in danger, which is tantamount to rebellion. Even if you kill the Japanese major general, you will not be wronged at all.

I have to say that this adaptation of "Liangjian" is extremely outrageous and blind.

In the war of besieging Ping'an County, it's easy to say in other places. Although some Italian guns are outrageous, at least they are not too much.

《亮剑》也算抗日神剧?当然,五十步和一百步的区别

In the war of besieging Ping'an County, it's easy to say in other places. Although some Italian guns are outrageous, at least they are not too much.

However, on the outskirts of Ping'an County, a company of the Eighth Route Army attached to the district team of the county brigade can stop the eight hour attack of about 4000 people of a heavy-duty regiment of the Japanese army, which is somewhat outrageous.

Please note that blocking the Japanese army for eight hours does not mean that it must not be possible. If you play skillfully like Ding Wei, blow up the bridge, bury mines on the road, shoot lengbuding, confuse the other party, make the Japanese reinforcements break their pants and wrap their legs, and delay the other party for eight hours is no problem.

《亮剑》也算抗日神剧?当然,五十步和一百步的区别

However, if we build a blocking position and fight the enemy hard, a Japanese heavy loaded regiment that has received a dead order for reinforcement can only break through the blocking of an ordinary company of the Eighth Route Army. We should know that the national armies of the two divisions could not resist the attack of one Japanese regiment in the war of resistance against Japan. This is not a problem that can be solved by fighting spirit,

In the great victory of Pingxingguan, more than 10000 people from the 115th division participated in the war or ambushed. From 7 a.m. to the afternoon, more than 1000 Japanese troops were destroyed. The total number of Japanese troops participating in the war, including the reinforcements, was more than 4000. Think about the Eighth Route Army, a company that survived only 200 people in the "shining sword", which is equivalent to doing the work of tens of thousands of people in the 115th division. Is it divine?

《亮剑》也算抗日神剧?当然,五十步和一百步的区别

Li Yunlong's graduation thesis in the military academy. According to the original work of "bright sword", the title of Li Yunlong's thesis should be on special operations. He was inspired by Yamamoto secret service team. It is more appropriate to arrange the plot in such a way that it can echo back and forth.

However, in the TV series "bright sword", the screenwriter changed Li Yunlong's paper into "on the spirit of bright sword", which convinced him.

Why should Nanjing military academy be established? Why did so many senior generals leave their jobs to study in the college? Why discuss "less steel and more gas" on the Korean battlefield? It's not because the army wants to modernize and can't just rely on hard work.

Well, according to the plot of "shining sword", the state has paid Li Yunlong for a class in the military academy in vain. Let you learn modern military. Do you want to write a paper or talk about the traditional spirit? Do you want to go to the military academy? You majored in astrophysics. Your graduation thesis is a change of Xuanwu. Can you pass it?

《亮剑》也算抗日神剧?当然,五十步和一百步的区别

The above part is just a part of the divine drama that the author picked out from the plot of Liangjian. These examples can show that there is a divine drama component in Liangjian, and it is not rare to study it carefully. The main purpose of divine drama adaptation is to shape the image of Li Yunlong. It has to be said that this purpose must have been achieved.

Well, it's not too much to say that "Liangjian" is also an anti Japanese drama. In a certain sense, the difference between "Liangjian" and the later "hand tearing devils" Anti Japanese drama is only 50 steps and 100 steps.

《亮剑》也算抗日神剧?当然,五十步和一百步的区别

2、 Why is anti Japanese drama popular?

The middle reason is very complex, not a simple factor.

Capital, there is no difference between the capital invested in TV dramas and other capital. The primary purpose is to maintain capital and the secondary purpose is to make money. When an anti Japanese drama with some divine drama color is popular, more anti Japanese dramas will naturally appear to catch up with the heat. When everyone rushes in, the natural creativity and materials are not enough, so the "legend" color of some TV dramas becomes more and more outrageous.

Similarly, after "lurking" became popular, a large number of spy war dramas with divine drama color emerged. Finally, even spy war idol dramas came out, so I asked if you were satisfied.

《亮剑》也算抗日神剧?当然,五十步和一百步的区别

The best one is the sword itself. Li Yunlong's version has the color of divine drama. What should we do when remaking the second and third editions? We can only develop in a more divine direction, so when we came to the third edition of sword, we saw hair gel, coffee, big villa and small white shoes.

Don't laugh, you see "Detective Conan" is the same. At first, it was a mystery play, then it became an action film, and finally it became a science fiction film.

《亮剑》也算抗日神剧?当然,五十步和一百步的区别

Screenwriters and directors, relatively speaking, do not have many writers in the Anti Japanese God drama, because screenwriters do not have much discourse power in the domestic film and television industry. If the discourse power of screenwriters is relatively large, there will not be so many wonderful dramas. I believe that most screenwriters have enough cultivation in literature and history, and people who do not understand history can not make up Anti Japanese War dramas.

Similarly, those fireworks, props and others in the Anti Japanese divine drama crew don't have to carry the pot, because most practitioners don't eat dry meals. They know some common sense in history and military, and won't hand over the five or six flushes to the Eighth Route military.

Directors are not necessarily. Directors in the domestic film and television industry have a relatively large voice, but few of them really understand history and military. Just as few of them really understand directors in history, they are separated from each other. Many directors are conceited and don't like learning. According to their wild ideas, the probability of divine drama is not generally large.

《亮剑》也算抗日神剧?当然,五十步和一百步的区别

Audience, in the final analysis, the root cause of the popularity of Anti Japanese divine dramas is also the factor of the audience. If the audience can work together like a collective boycott of Liangjian 3, the Anti Japanese divine dramas will not be rampant. They are afraid that some of the audience will chase after the divine dramas while scolding the divine dramas, especially those starring Aidou.

Finally, on the whole, Li Youbin's version of "shining sword" is certainly a good play, but its shortcomings do not hide its shortcomings, but it has indeed driven a part of the upsurge of Anti Japanese divine drama, which can not be denied.